Shooter Cleared In Bystander’s Death In Stand Your Ground Case - WSPA.com

Shooter Cleared In Bystander’s Death In Stand Your Ground Case

Posted: Updated:
The central question of this case: Are people who shoot an innocent bystander while defending their own lives protected under the Stand Your Ground law? The central question of this case: Are people who shoot an innocent bystander while defending their own lives protected under the Stand Your Ground law?
COLUMBIA, S.C. -

A man shoots and kills an unarmed teen, but won't be prosecuted for it.

Just this week, a judge decided he's immune from prosecution under South Carolina's "Stand Your Ground” law.

The central question of this case: Are people who shoot an innocent bystander while defending their own lives protected under the Stand Your Ground law?

While Shannon Scott's teenage daughter hid under the kitchen table, Scott went out onto his stoop and shot into a car out front.

He thought it was a car full of people who followed his daughter home and were shooting at her.

But he shot at the wrong car and killed an innocent bystander, 17-year-old Darrell Niles.

Three years later, Scott's off the hook.

Judge Maité Murphy said he's immune from prosecution.

In the order granting immunity, the judge said Scott was "reasonable to be in fear of the victim” and believed the attack would continue if he did not act.

“I think, if you look at it from the perspective of the father, he did have reason to believe that his life was at risk, that his daughter's life was at risk. So therefore, as the law is written, there's really not much the prosecution could have done," said University of South Carolina law professor Colin Miller.

David Blanton is retired from the Spartanburg County Sheriff's Office. Now he teaches a concealed weapons permit course. He said he disagrees with the judge's decision.

“If someone is a clear and present threat to myself and my family, I'm going to react to it. Someone that might be? No. I'm not going to shoot that person,” said Blanton.

And he said this judge's decision won't change how he would teach his students to react in a similar situation.

“The Supreme Court can say that and I'm still going to say shooting at someone that you think might have been a problem, but you're not 100 percent sure -- you don't do that," said Blanton.

Fifth Judicial Circuit Solicitor Dan Johnson is appealing the judge's decision to the South Carolina Supreme Court.

Right now there are no Stand Your Ground cases before the state Supreme Court. All of them have been dismissed.

For someone to be granted immunity through Stand Your Ground, that person has to demonstrate three things. First, the person must be in a place where they have a right to be. Second, they cannot be "engaged in unlawful activity." Third, deadly force can only be used if the person reasonably believes it's necessary to prevent great bodily injury or a violent crime.


Related:
Stand Your Ground Laws
  • Top StoriesTop StoriesMore>>

  • Greenville Man Arrested, Charged With Lexington County Shooting

    Greenville Man Arrested, Charged With Lexington County Shooting

    Wednesday, August 27 2014 10:48 AM EDT2014-08-27 14:48:38 GMT
    Mugshot: Juan Hernandez-Torres, Lexington County Sheriff's OfficeMugshot: Juan Hernandez-Torres, Lexington County Sheriff's Office
    A man from Greenville has been arrested and charged with a shooting in Lexington County. Lexington County Sheriff's Office spokesman John Allard stated that Juan Hernandez-Torres, 38, was arrested after a traffic stop and brief manhunt in Laurens County Tuesday night.
    A man from Greenville has been arrested and charged with a shooting in Lexington County. Lexington County Sheriff's Office spokesman John Allard stated that Juan Hernandez-Torres, 38, was arrested after a traffic stop and brief manhunt in Laurens County Tuesday night.
  • 15 Children Removed From Woodruff Home, 7 Adults Charged

    15 Children Removed From Woodruff Home, 7 Adults Charged

    Wednesday, August 27 2014 10:37 AM EDT2014-08-27 14:37:06 GMT
    15 children were removed from a home in Woodruff and warrants have been signed for seven adults who were responsible for their care.15 children were removed from a home in Woodruff and warrants have been signed for seven adults who were responsible for their care.
    Fifteen children were removed from a home in Woodruff and warrants have been signed for seven adults who were responsible for their care. The Spartanburg County Sheriff's Office Special Victims Unit worked the case Tuesday at a home on Hunter Road.
    Fifteen children were removed from a home in Woodruff and warrants have been signed for seven adults who were responsible for their care. The Spartanburg County Sheriff's Office Special Victims Unit worked the case Tuesday at a home on Hunter Road.
  • Fountain Inn Man Killed On Greenpond Road

    Fountain Inn Man Killed On Greenpond Road

    Wednesday, August 27 2014 9:30 AM EDT2014-08-27 13:30:18 GMT
    1 dead after crash in Greenville County.1 dead after crash in Greenville County.
    A Fountain Inn man was killed in an accident on Greenpond Road early Wednesday morning. Donald Lance Tucker, 29, was killed in the crash near Martin Road just after 12:30 a.m. 
    A Fountain Inn man was killed in an accident on Greenpond Road early Wednesday morning. Donald Lance Tucker, 29, was killed in the crash near Martin Road just after 12:30 a.m. according to the Greenville County Coroner.
Powered by WorldNow

250 International Dr.
Spartanburg, S.C. 29303

Telephone: 864.576.7777
Fax: 864.587.5430
Email: webmaster@wspa.com

Can't find something?
Powered by WorldNow
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 Media General Communications Holdings, LLC. A Media General Company.