Haley Agreement on Travel Costs Raising New Questions - WSPA.com

Haley Agreement on Travel Costs Raising New Questions

Posted: Updated:
COLUMBIA, S.C. -

An agreement over the costs of Gov. Nikki Haley's security detail when at campaign events was supposed to settle any questions, but has instead raised new ones. She signed the agreement earlier this month with the State Law Enforcement Division and State Ethics Commission. The agreement, for the first time in writing, spells out when a governor will reimburse the state for some of the costs of her state-provided security detail.

For example, if the governor is at a campaign-related event out of state, her campaign would pay for travel, lodging, meals, and any overtime for her security detail. But, according to the agreement, "wages and salaries are not reimbursable because they are not an additional cost to the state." Her campaign says that, since the agents who are part of her security detail are already being paid by the state, there's no additional cost to taxpayers whether they're protecting her at an official state function or at a campaign function. But since overtime would be an additional expense, her campaign would pay for that.

But John Crangle, state director of the watchdog group Common Cause, says, "We don't think the taxpayers should have to pay those costs, that those costs ought to be paid by the governor's campaign committee." He says even though the agents in her security detail are already being paid by the state, it's not necessarily true that they have to be protecting her even when she's not at a campaign event.

He points to the fact that Bureau of Protective Services officers are paid to protect the Governor's Mansion and the Statehouse, so she shouldn't need a separate security detail in those places. And he says there's no requirement that a governor have a security detail at a campaign event, so if she wants one she should reimburse the state for the cost of her state-provided detail or hire a private security  company.

He also questions whether the State Ethics Commission even has the authority to enter into the agreement, since it's not mentioned in the state budget proviso that requires the security detail. That proviso says, "The State Law Enforcement Division, the Department of Public Safety, and the Department of Natural Resources shall provide a security detail to the Governor in a manner agreed to by the State Law Enforcement Division, the Department of Public Safety, the Department of Natural Resources, and the Office of Governor."

Crangle says not requiring the Haley campaign to pay the entire cost of her security detail violates state law. Section 8-13-765 of the state Code of Laws says, "No person may use government personnel, equipment, materials, or an office building in an election campaign. The provisions of this subsection do not apply to a public official's use of an official residence."

Crangle argues that having SLED or DNR agents, who are government personnel, work as her security detail at campaign events violates that law.

But SLED spokesman Thom Berry says that's not true because the members of the governor's security detail are not working for her campaign or doing anything campaign-related; they're simply protecting her. "That's been something that's been provided for all governors," he says of the security detail. "They don't do political campaigning. They don't do any political campaign work. They're there to provide security for the governor."

State Ethics Commission director Herb Hayden says, "Historically, it appears that there has been some confusion with the interpretation of the necessary requirements for a protection detail for the Governor and the equally necessary prohibitions contained in the state's campaign finance statutes with regard to the use of state assets in an election campaign. This MOA (Memorandum Of Agreement) was a collaborative effort between the three agencies to ensure that there is a clear understanding of the statutory requirements regarding the use of the Governor's protection detail while attending campaign related events.  This agreement will serve as a benchmark for all future campaign activities and bring clarity to an obvious area of confusion."

Crangle agrees that it's an area of confusion. "I think the state law probably needs to be clarified, to make it very clear that when she's involved in campaign-related activities, her campaign pays the taxpayers 100 percent of the associated costs. That would make it very clear that taxpayers are not subsidizing her campaigns," he says.

  • Top StoriesTop StoriesMore>>

  • Union Sheriff: Judicial System Failing Citizens After Robbery Arrests

    Union Sheriff: Judicial System Failing Citizens After Robbery Arrests

    Wednesday, April 23 2014 3:55 PM EDT2014-04-23 19:55:39 GMT
    Porshia Gage, 23 and Matthew Williams, Jr., 26Porshia Gage, 23 and Matthew Williams, Jr., 26
    Several law enforcement agencies across the Upstate say they have two suspects in custody who were involved in a string of armed robberies in at least 10 jurisdictions dating back about one month.
    Several law enforcement agencies across the Upstate say they have two suspects in custody who were involved in a string of armed robberies in at least 10 jurisdictions dating back about one month.
  • No Suspension For Simpsonville Mayor Eichor Until May

    No Suspension For Simpsonville Mayor Eichor Until May

    Wednesday, April 23 2014 2:27 PM EDT2014-04-23 18:27:21 GMT
    Simpsonville Mayor Perry Eichor won't be suspended from office by Governor Haley until at least next month. The governor indicated she would suspend Eichor once she got indictments against him.
    Simpsonville Mayor Perry Eichor won't be suspended from office by Governor Haley until at least next month. The governor indicated she would suspend Eichor once she got indictments against him.
  • Gaffney Woman Dies From Vehicle Crash Injuries

    Gaffney Woman Dies From Vehicle Crash Injuries

    Wednesday, April 23 2014 11:15 AM EDT2014-04-23 15:15:32 GMT
    The Cherokee County Coroner says a 73-year-old Gaffney woman injured in a car accident last week has died.The Cherokee County Coroner says a 73-year-old Gaffney woman injured in a car accident last week has died.
    The Cherokee County Coroner says a 73-year-old Gaffney woman injured in a car accident last week has died. Coroner Dennis Fowler says Rachel Lail Smith died Tuesday night at 10 at Spartanburg Regional Medical Center.
    The Cherokee County Coroner says a 73-year-old Gaffney woman injured in a car accident last week has died. Coroner Dennis Fowler says Rachel Lail Smith died Tuesday night at 10 at Spartanburg Regional Medical Center.
Powered by WorldNow

250 International Dr.
Spartanburg, S.C. 29303

Telephone: 864.576.7777
Fax: 864.587.5430
Email: webmaster@wspa.com

Can't find something?
Powered by WorldNow
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 Media General Communications Holdings, LLC. A Media General Company.